Jan 9, 2015 | Making Community

Oh the irony: freedom of expression in a corporate media world

I’m writing this as the radio airs a live report of gunfire. The French police have just killed the two brothers who hunted down particular editorial workers at the satirical Paris magazine two days ago, murdering 12.

A bloodbath over hand-drawn images is over (for now), while the global reaction is unfolding in drawings.

PictureFrench illustrator Lucille Clerc’s image that she posted on Twitter went viral after it appeared on a fake Banksy Instagram account.

The call has been sent – and heard – far and wide: Defend free speech by publishing the triggering images of Mohammed, and by taking up the pen or pencil in a massive freedom of expression effort. (Some early responses by cartoonists can be seen here.)

As much as I am deeply offended by some of the cartoons printed in Charlie Hebdo (like this one of the naked young woman with her burqa up her ass, in line with the magazine’s support of banning women’s right to choose) I will defend all extremists’ right to draw and publish extremist drawings. Respecting the right of all dissenting voices is part of a (still mythical) free and open society that nurtures rational thought and behaviour. The world witnessed the alternative on Wednesday morning.

Here in Vancouver, former Province editorial cartoonist Bob Krieger took to the drawing board hours after the news of the murders of his fellow cartoonists and others.


Picture

But you won’t find this one-panel in the local newspaper anymore; the last Province cartoonist was let go in 2013, the way cartoonists have been unloaded all over the country by their corporate media owners.

Surely it was simply a cost-saving measure, but the result is a pitiful amount of visual commentary, and a corporate curbing of free speech.

This week the Province (owned by Postmedia which also owns the only other paid daily newspaper in this town) ran a guest column on the topic of the need for cartoonists’  freedom of expression by Aislin (Terry Mosher) of the Montreal Gazette. That one voice ran in other Postmedia outlets including the Regina Leader-Post, Windsor Star and a whole whack of online news aggregators. And nothing against Aislin, but I miss our own, Vancouver-based critical drawings as we try to absorb the unfathomable. But as Krieger told The Tyee after he was shown the door, “corporate media is way too controlling and they don’t want as much of a variety of opinion as newspapers should have.” 


PictureYou can’t keep good cartoonists down.

Yet suddenly Canada’s corporate media can’t get enough visual commentaries, and entire pages have been dedicated to the drawings, sometimes in full colour – a dream to many cartoonists. But look closer at the spread in yesterday’s National Post  (also owned by Postmedia) and it’s clear that less than half of the cartoonists are actually employed by newspapers. 

You can see the irony here. Freedom of expression: Yes! … unless there’s more money in clickbait that has no relevance to local readership.

Cartoonists are compelled to make art, to share their expression freely. The papers aren’t paying like they used to but the people are clearly paying attention, via social media retweets, hits, and followers. There’s a lot of value in that.

It’s astounding that the penny has not yet dropped.